Current:Home > ScamsSpecial counsel Jack Smith argues Judge Tanya Chutkan shouldn't recuse herself in Trump case -Wealth Momentum Network
Special counsel Jack Smith argues Judge Tanya Chutkan shouldn't recuse herself in Trump case
View
Date:2025-04-26 06:34:03
Washington — Special counsel Jack Smith filed a blistering motion in response to former President Donald Trump's request that the judge overseeing his federal 2020 election interference criminal case recuse herself.
"There is no valid basis, under the relevant law and facts, for the Honorable Tanya S. Chutkan, United States District Judge for the District of Columbia, to disqualify herself in this proceeding," Smith wrote in a 20-page filing an hour before a deadline set by Chutkan to respond.
- Trump's 4 indictments in detail: A quick-look guide to charges, trial dates and key players for each case
He said that in seeking Chutkan's recusal, Trump "both takes out of context the Court's words from prior judicial proceedings and misstates the proper legal standards governing judicial recusals."
Smith also argued that Trump "cherry-picks" from two of Chutkan's sentencing hearings for two Capitol riot defendants, and in both cases, "the Court was appropriately responding to—and ultimately rejecting— a common argument raised by scores of January 6 offenders: that they deserved leniency because their actions were inspired by, or were not as serious as, those of others who contributed to the riot but had not been held responsible—including former president Donald J. Trump, the defendant in this case."
Trump's lawyers asked in a filing Monday that Chutkan remove herself from the case because of previous statements she had made in two separate Capitol riot sentencing hearings.
"Judge Chutkan has, in connection with other cases, suggested that President Trump should be prosecuted and imprisoned," Trump's lawyers wrote in their request. "Such statements, made before this case began and without due process, are inherently disqualifying."
They highlighted statements she made about the former president, including telling one Capitol riot defendant in October 2022 that the violent attempt to overthrow the government came from "blind loyalty to one person who, by the way, remains free to this day."
"The public meaning of this statement is inescapable — President Trump is free, but should not be," Trump's attorneys wrote.
But in his filing, Smith provided more extensive transcripts of the remarks Judge Chutkan had made in the two Capitol riot sentencing hearings to make the argument that the full transcripts show that she "did not state that [Trump] was legally or morally culpable for the events of January 6 or that he deserved punishment," but rather, that "the Court was engaged in its judicial responsibility to hear, acknowledge, and respond to [the Jan. 6 defendant's] sentencing allocution."
Addressing the emphasis placed by Trump's recusal motion on this phrase, "it's a blind loyalty to one person who, by the way, remains free to this day," Smith wrote, "From this simple statement of uncontroverted fact, the defendant purports to draw the 'inescapable' message that the Court believes that defendant Trump should be imprisoned. But the only inescapable thing about the Court's comment is that it stated an uncontested and accurate fact in response to a mitigation argument that the Court had heard many times before."
Smith argued Trump has not proven Chutkan made biased claims because he "must show that they display a deep-seated animosity toward him."
"The defendant cannot meet this heavy burden," Smith wrote.
"Because the defendant cannot point to any statements expressing actual bias, all he can say—and he says it repeatedly—is that the Court's comments 'suggest' some sort of bias or prejudice toward the defendant," Smith added.
Ultimately, it is up to Chutkan to decide whether her past statements create the perception of bias. A new judge would be assigned to the case if she recuses. Trump's attorneys could petition an appeals court to require her to recuse, but such efforts are often not successful.
Trump will be able to respond to Smith's counter-argument, and his deadline to do so is next week.
Fin Gomez and Graham Kates contributed to this report.
- In:
- Donald Trump
- United States Department of Justice
- Jack Smith
Caitlin Yilek is a politics reporter for CBS News Digital. Reach her at [email protected]. Follow her on Twitter: https://twitter.com/hausofcait
TwitterveryGood! (45)
Related
- Elon Musk's skyrocketing net worth: He's the first person with over $400 billion
- 2 girls, ages 7 and 11, killed after ATV crashes in Wisconsin
- Massachusetts House passes bill strengthening LGBTQ+ parents’ rights
- NBA legend Jerry West dies at 86
- Appeals court scraps Nasdaq boardroom diversity rules in latest DEI setback
- Newly deciphered manuscript is oldest written record of Jesus Christ's childhood, experts say
- Rhode Island lawmakers approve bill to ban “captive hunting” operations
- Ariana Grande 'upset' by 'innuendos' on her Nickelodeon shows after 'Quiet on Set' doc
- Moving abroad can be expensive: These 5 countries will 'pay' you to move there
- 'Inside Out 2' review: The battle between Joy, Anxiety feels very real in profound sequel
Ranking
- Hackers hit Rhode Island benefits system in major cyberattack. Personal data could be released soon
- Rob Schneider criticizes Will Smith for slapping Chris Rock at 2022 Academy Awards
- Walmart to change how you see prices in stores: What to know about digital shelf labels
- Ariana Grande 'upset' by 'innuendos' on her Nickelodeon shows after 'Quiet on Set' doc
- Backstage at New York's Jingle Ball with Jimmy Fallon, 'Queer Eye' and Meghan Trainor
- Nicola Coughlan Is a Blushing Bride at Bridgerton Red Carpet in London
- Get 50% Off J.Crew, Free First Aid Beauty Jumbo Products, 60% Off West Elm & More Deals
- Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Coming Up for Air
Recommendation
Trump wants to turn the clock on daylight saving time
Oregon man gets 2 years for drugging daughter's friends; the girls asked for more
Ex-officer in Mississippi gets 1 year in prison for forcing man to lick urine off jail floor
Ex-officer in Mississippi gets 1 year in prison for forcing man to lick urine off jail floor
Jamie Foxx reps say actor was hit in face by a glass at birthday dinner, needed stitches
A jet vanished over Lake Champlain 53 years ago. The wreckage was just found.
Large number of whale sightings off New England, including dozens of endangered sei whales
Impaired driver who fatally struck 2 Nevada state troopers gets maximum prison sentence